A comparative study of optimization methods and conventional methods for sampling design in fishery-independent surveys

文献类型： 外文期刊

第一作者： Liu, Yong

作者： Liu, Yong;Cheng, Jiahua;Chen, Yong

作者机构：

关键词： fishery-independent survey;geostatistics;optimization method;sampling design;simulation

期刊名称：ICES JOURNAL OF MARINE SCIENCE （ 影响因子：3.593； 五年影响因子：4.037 ）

ISSN：

年卷期：

页码：

收录情况： SCI

摘要： We have introduced and evaluated a procedure, the constrained spatial simulated annealing method, for developing an optimal sampling design for fishery-independent surveys. We used two criterion functions, minimization of the mean of the shortest distance (MMSD) and uniform distribution of point pairs for variogram estimation (WM), and three arrangements of the two criteria, all WM, all MMSD, and a combination of MMSD (2/3 of samples) and WM (1/3), to construct three optimized sampling designs (denoted as Designs I, II, and III, respectively). These three designs were compared in a simulation study with systematic sampling (Design IV) and stratified random sampling designs (Design V), commonly used in fishery-independent surveys. Three levels of sample size (small, medium, and large) were considered in the simulation study developed using a geostatistical approach. The results showed that for parameter estimation of the spatial covariance function, Design III was better than the other designs at relatively small sample size and Design II performed better than the other designs at relatively large sample size. For estimating fish stock abundance, the performance of the designs considered in this study can be ranked as follows: Design II > Design IV > Design III > Design V > Design I. It is clearly important to evaluate and improve sampling design based on historical survey data. Such a study allows us to identify an optimal sampling design to balance the quality of the data collected and the costs of the sampling programme, leading to the development and optimization of a sustainable and fishery-independent monitoring programme.

分类号： P7

  • 相关文献

[1]Comparison of Two Optimization Algorithms for Estimating Regional Winter Wheat Yield by Integrating MODIS Leaf Area Index and World Food Studies Model. Tian, Liyan,Huang, Jianxi,Su, Wei,Zhang, Chao,Liu, Junming,Li, Zhongxia,Wang, Limin.

[2]An adaptive sampling method based on optimized sampling design for fishery-independent surveys with comparisons with conventional designs. Liu, Yong,Lu, Jianjian,Liu, Yong,Cheng, Jiahua,Chen, Yong.

[3]Comparison of spatial sampling schemes for crop sown acreage estimation in large-scale inventories. Wang Di,Chen Zhongxin,Zhou Qingbo,Liu Jia. 2016

[4]Spatial variability and patterns of surface soil moisture in a field plot of karst area in southwest China. Zhang, J. G.,Chen, H. S.,Su, Y. R.,Zhang, W.,Zhang, J. G.,Shi, Y.,Liang, H. B.,Shen, G. M.,Chen, H. S.,Su, Y. R.,Zhang, W.,Kong, X. L..

[5]Geospatial Based Assessment of Spatial Variation of Groundwater Nitrate Nitrogen in Shandong Intensive Farming Regions of China. Huang, J.,Su, W.,Xu, J.,Liu, X.,Liu, J.,Wang, L.,Ramsankaran, Raaj.

[6]Spatiotemporal patterns of the fish assemblages downstream of the Gezhouba Dam on the Yangtze River. Tao JiangPing,Gong YuTian,Yang Zhi,Chang JianBo,Tao JiangPing,Gong YuTian,Yang Zhi,Chang JianBo,Tan XiChang. 2012

[7]Error modeling based on geostatistics for uncertainty analysis in crop mapping using Gaofen-1 multispectral imagery. You, Jiong,Pei, Zhiyuan. 2015

[8]Predicting Grassland Leaf Area Index in the Meadow Steppes of Northern China: A Comparative Study of Regression Approaches and Hybrid Geostatistical Methods. Li, Zhenwang,Tang, Huan,Yang, Fan,Chen, Baorui,Wang, Xu,Xin, Xiaoping,Wang, Jianghao,Ge, Yong,Huang, Chengquan. 2016

[9]Elevation and Land Use Types Have Significant Impacts on Spatial Variability of Soil Organic Matter Content in Hani Terraced Field of Yuanyang County, China. Li Feng-bo,Zhou Xi-yue,Xu Chun-chun,Feng Jin-fei,Fang Fu-ping,Lu Guang-de,Ni Hui-xiang,Yue chao,Yang Xiu-mei. 2015

[10]Cropland soil organic matter content change in Northeast China, 1985-2005. Yao, Yanmin,Ye, Liming,Tang, Pengqin,Wang, Deying,Si, Haiqing,Hu, Wenjun,Yao, Yanmin,Ye, Liming,Tang, Huajun,Tang, Pengqin,Wang, Deying,Si, Haiqing,Hu, Wenjun,Van Ranst, Eric,Ye, Liming,Van Ranst, Eric,Tang, Huajun. 2015

[11]A simple assessment on spatial variability of rice yield and selected soil chemical properties of paddy fields in South China. Liu, Zhanjun,Zhou, Wei,He, Ping,Lei, Qiuliang,Liang, Guoqing,Liu, Zhanjun,Shen, Jianbo.

[12]Cost-effective sampling of Cs-137-derived net soil redistribution: part 1-estimating the spatial mean across scales of variation. Li, Y.,Nyamdavaa, B.,Yu, H.,Davaasuren, D.,Zoljargal, K.,Chappell, A..

[13]Optimal design on samples layout of spatial sampling schemes for estimating winter wheat planting acreage. Wang Di,Chen Zhongxin,Zhou Qingbo,An Yi. 2014

[14]Land use changes induced soil organic carbon variations in agricultural soils of Fuyang County, China. Qiu, Lefeng,Zhu, Jinxia,Wang, Ke,Deng, Jinsong,Zhu, Yuanhong,Hong, Yang. 2013

[15]Spatial variability of soil nutrients and GIS-based nutrient management in Yongji County, China. Zhang, Qiang,Yang, Zhiping,Zhang, Qiang,Yang, Zhiping,Zhang, Jianjie,Chen, Mingchang,Li, Yong,Chen, Deli.

[16]Simulation Research on Diffusion of Agricultural Science and Technology for Peasant. Ma, Li,Chu, Xia-ling,Huang, Xiujie,Xiong, Ruiquan,Li, Huanhuan,Lin, Qun. 2014

[17]An integrated model to simulate sown area changes for major crops at a global scale. Wu WenBin,Ryosuke, Shibasaki,Shi Yun,Wu WenBin,Yang Peng,Zhou QingBo,Tang HuaJun,Wu WenBin,Yang Peng,Zhou QingBo,Tang HuaJun,Meng ChaoYing. 2008

[18]Simulating soil water and solute transport in a soil-wheat system using an improved genetic algorithm. Luo, Changshou,Sun, Sufen,Zhang, Junfeng,Zuo, Qiang,Li, Baoguo. 2008

[19]Maize production emulation system based on cooperative models. Li, Shijuan,Zhu, Yeping. 2008

[20]Data fusion for management of outdoor stored grain. Sun, L,Zhu, ZS. 2002

作者其他论文 更多>>

微信小程序