The effect of no-till on organic C storage in Chinese soils should not be overemphasized: A meta-analysis

文献类型： 外文期刊

第一作者： Du, Zhangliu

作者： Du, Zhangliu;Zhang, Qingzhong;Li, Guichun;Angers, Denis A.;Ren, Tusheng

作者机构：

关键词： No-till;Soil organic carbon;Equivalent soil mass;Fixed depth;Meta-analysis;Climate change mitigation

期刊名称：AGRICULTURE ECOSYSTEMS & ENVIRONMENT （ 影响因子：5.567； 五年影响因子：6.064 ）

ISSN：

年卷期：

页码：

收录情况： SCI

摘要： No-till (NT) has been widely regarded as a potential option to enhance soil organic carbon (SOC) sequestration and thus mitigate climate change. However, recent studies have shown that previous estimates of SOC storage under NT seem to be overestimated due to shallow sampling and improper SOC accounting. In China, the overall trend and magnitude of changes in SOC storage in response to NT adoption remain inconclusive. Here we use a meta-analysis to assess the relative change in SOC storage (profiles >= 20 cm) based on 95 comparisons between NT and conventional tillage (CT) from 57 experimental sites (>= 3 years) covering various cropping systems, soil types, and climatic regions of China. The results revealed that compared to CT, adopting NT led to SOC accumulation in the upper 20 cm layer and SOC depletion in the 30-40 cm layer. On average, NT improved SOC stocks over CT by 3.8% [95% confidence interval (CI): 1.4%-6.3%; P=0.005] and 5.1% (95%CI: 2.5%-7.7%; P < 0.001) as represented by the equivalent soil mass (ESM) and fixed-depth (FD) approaches, respectively. The relative change in SOC storage rate under NT over tilled soil for the top 30 cm layer was therefore significantly higher (Mean: 0.300 Mg ha(-1) yr(-1), 95%CI: 0.054-0.547; P < 0.001) calculated by FD approach than that by ESM (Mean: 0.141 Mg ha(-1) yr(-1), 95%CI: -0.102-0384; P=0.100). Further analysis suggested that the effect of NT on SOC storage was significant with residue retained, double cropping systems, and in the coarse textured soils. We conclude that although NT was an effective agronomy option for soil conservation in China, the potential for mitigation climate change through increased SOC sequestration by NT should not be amplified. (C) 2016 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

分类号： S

  • 相关文献

[1]Potential Effect of Conservation Tillage on Sustainable Land Use: A Review of Global Long-Term Studies. Wang Xiao-Bin,Cai Dian-Xiong,Hoogmoed, W. B.,Oenema, O.,Perdok, U. D..

[2]Transition from intensive tillage to no-till enhances carbon sequestration in microaggregates of surface soil in the North China Plain. Du, Zhangliu,Zhang, Qingzhong,Ren, Tusheng,Ren, Tusheng,Hu, Chunsheng.

[3]Tillage and crop residue effects on rainfed wheat and maize production in northern China. Wang, Xiaobin,Wu, Huijun,Dai, Kuai,Zhang, Dingchen,Feng, Zonghui,Zhao, Quansheng,Wu, Xueping,Jin, Ke,Cai, Dianxiong,Wang, Xiaobin,Wu, Huijun,Dai, Kuai,Zhang, Dingchen,Feng, Zonghui,Zhao, Quansheng,Wu, Xueping,Jin, Ke,Cai, Dianxiong,Cai, Dianxiong,Oenema, O.,Hoogmoed, W. B.. 2012

[4]Dryland maize yields and water use efficiency in response to tillage/crop stubble and nutrient management practices in China. Wang, Xiaobin,Dai, Kuai,Zhang, Dingchen,Zhang, Xiaoming,Wang, Yan,Zhao, Quansheng,Cai, Dianxiong,Wang, Xiaobin,Dai, Kuai,Zhang, Dingchen,Zhang, Xiaoming,Wang, Yan,Zhao, Quansheng,Cai, Dianxiong,Cai, Dianxiong,Hoogmoed, W. B.,Oenema, O.. 2011

[5]Earthworms affect plant growth and resistance against herbivores: A meta-analysis. Liu, Manqiang,Hu, Feng,Xiao, Zhenggao,Kergunteuil, Alan,Le Bayon, Renee-Claire,Rasmann, Sergio,Wang, Xie,Koricheva, Julia,Liu, Manqiang,Hu, Feng. 2018

[6]Effect of Diacylglycerol Supplementation on Fasting Serum Triacylglycerol Concentration: a Meta-Analysis. Wang, Wenliang,Xu, Tongcheng,Zhu, Qingjun,Cheng, Anwei,Du, Fangling,Xu, Tongcheng,Li, Duo,Li, Xia. 2010

[7]Effect of Diacylglycerol on Postprandial Serum Triacylglycerol Concentration: A Meta-analysis. Xu, Tongcheng,Zhang, Zhiguo,Li, Duo,Li, Xia,Xu, Tongcheng,Ma, Xiaohang,Zhang, Tiansong. 2009

[8]Systematic review and meta-analysis of soy products consumption in patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus. Yang, Bin,Chen, Ying,Xu, Tongchen,Yu, Yinghua,Huang, Tao,Hu, Xiaojie,Li, Duo,Xu, Tongchen,Yu, Yinghua. 2011

[9]Effect of diacylglycerol on body weight: a meta-analysis. Xu, Tongcheng,Zhang, Zhiguo,Li, Duo,Xu, Tongcheng,Li, Xia,Ma, Xiaohang. 2008

[10]Combining QTL and candidate gene analysis with phenotypic model to unravel the relationship between lodging and related traits in soybean. Chen, Haifeng,Yang, Zhonglu,Chen, Limiao,Zhang, Chanjuan,Yuan, Songli,Zhang, Xiaojuan,Qiu, Dezhen,Wan, Qiao,Chen, Shuilian,Shan, Zhihui,Zhou, Xinan,Zhan, Yong.

[11]Integrated assessment of the impact of enhanced-efficiency nitrogen fertilizer on N2O emission and crop yield. Feng, Jinfei,Li, Fengbo,Fang, Fuping,Feng, Jinfei,Deng, Aixing,Feng, Xiaomin,Zhang, Weijian.

[12]Higher yields and lower methane emissions with new rice cultivars. Hu, Shuijin,Yan, Xiaojun,Wang, Lili,Zhang, Yi,Zhang, Weijian,Jiang, Yu,Zhang, Jun,Song, Zhenwei,Zheng, Chengyan,Deng, Aixing,Zhang, Weijian,van Groenigen, Kees Jan,van Groenigen, Kees Jan,van Kessel, Chris,Linquist, Bruce A.,Huang, Shan,Hungate, Bruce A.,Hu, Shuijin,Wu, Lianhai,Chen, Jin,Hang, Xiaoning,Horwath, William R.,Ye, Rongzhong.

[13]Efficacy of progesterone supplementation during early pregnancy in cows: A meta-analysis. Yan, Leyan,Shi, Zhendan,Robinson, Robert,Mann, George.

[14]Predicting plant response to arbuscular mycorrhizas: The role of host functional traits. Yang, Haishui,Xu, Jianglai,Guo, Yi,Dai, Yajun,Bian, Xinmin,Koide, Roger T.,Xu, Mingmin,Bian, Liping,Zhang, Qian.

[15]Meta-analysis of food processing on pesticide residues in fruits. Liang, Y.,Liu, Y.,Liu, X. J.,Liang, Y.,Ding, Y.,Liu, X. J..

[16]Soybean plant height QTL mapping and meta-analysis for mining candidate genes. Yin, Zhengong,Qi, Huidong,Chen, Qingshan,Zhang, Zhanguo,Jiang, Hongwei,Zhu, Rongsheng,Hu, Zhenbang,Wu, Xiaoxia,Xin, Dawei,Qi, Zhaoming,Yin, Zhengong,Jiang, Hongwei,Liu, Chunyan,Hu, Guohua,Li, Candong,Zhang, Yong.

[17]Meta-analysis of the effect of overexpression of CBF/DREB family genes on drought stress response. Dong, Chao,Cheng, Zong-Ming,Ma, Yuanchun,Wisniewski, Michael,Cheng, Zong-Ming.

[18]Genetic analysis of Verticillium wilt resistance in a backcross inbred line population and a meta-analysis of quantitative trait loci for disease resistance in cotton. Jinfa Zhang,Jiwen Yu,Wenfeng Pei,Xingli Li,Joseph Said,Mingzhou Song,Soum Sanogo. 2015

[19]p53 codon 72 polymorphism and recurrent pregnancy loss: a meta-analysis. Tang, Wenru,Chan, Ying,Wu, Xiaomin,Luo, Ying,Zhou, Xuhong. 2011

[20]Meta-analysis of constitutive QTLs for disease resistance in maize and its synteny conservation in the rice genome. Zhao, L.,Wang, Q. Y.,Liu, H. J.,Zhang, C. X.,Li, X. H.. 2015

作者其他论文 更多>>

微信小程序