Life cycle assessment of dairy production systems in Inner Mongolia: reiterate LCA modeling approaches

文献类型： 外文期刊

第一作者： Wu, Susie Ruqun

作者： Wu, Susie Ruqun;Liu, Xinchao;Wang, Lulu;Xin, Xiaoping;Shao, Changliang;Wu, Susie Ruqun;Liu, Xinchao;Chen, Jiquan

作者机构：

关键词： Attributional LCA; Decisional LCA; Consequential LCA; Dairy production

期刊名称：INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT （ 影响因子：4.141； 五年影响因子：5.553 ）

ISSN： 0948-3349

年卷期： 2021 年 26 卷 8 期

页码：

收录情况： SCI

摘要： Purpose The selection of different LCA modeling approaches can lead to inconsistent applications and results. Here, we proposed decision trees to identify the most appropriate modeling approach (attributional/decisional/consequential LCA (ALCA/DLCA/CLCA)) and applied them to examine both direct and indirect impacts of different dairy production systems in Inner Mongolia (IM), China-a pastoral area subject to policy debates about modernizing traditional pastoralism systems characterized by low productivity. Methods Decision trees to select appropriate LCA modeling approaches were developed by reviewing various international standards and guidelines. Using Hulunbuir grassland as the study site, three streamlined LCAs were then conducted with a functional unit of 1 kg fat-and-protein-corrected milk (FPCM) following the proposed approach. ALCA was used to examine the direct environmental impacts of the current extensive pastoralism system (EPS). DLCA was used to explore the direct environmental impacts of a future intensive production system (IPS). CLCA was applied to assess the direct and indirect environmental impacts of transitioning EPS to IPS-a transitional production system (TPS). Results and discussion EPS showed moderate environmental impacts associated with high uncertainty due to its low productivity and data variability among surveyed farms. Following DLCA and using presumed data from a dairy company's ESG report, IPS received relatively low impact scores due to a change in its energy structure. After incorporating indirect impacts, the CLCA results for TPS showed distinctive patterns with new environmental hotspots identified. Although the results were subject to limitations on data accuracy, a key policy implication lay in the shifting of environmental burdens due to decision making under both IPS and TPS following a sensitivity analysis. Conclusions The importance of selecting an appropriate LCA modeling approach under different study goals was reiterated, followed by three case studies in IM, China. If the current EPS were to be replaced, careful planning would be needed to avoid environmental burden shifting, with both direct and indirect impacts needing to be assessed thoroughly. Alternative emission reduction plans for EPS lie in controlling direct emissions and improving its production efficiency and energy structure.

分类号：

  • 相关文献
作者其他论文 更多>>

微信小程序