Comparative study of estimation methods for genomic breeding values

文献类型: 外文期刊

第一作者: Wang, Chonglong

作者: Wang, Chonglong;Qian, Rong;Wang, Chonglong;Zhang, Qin;Jiang, Li;Ding, Xiangdong;Wang, Chonglong;Zhao, Yaofeng

作者机构:

关键词: Genomic selection;Estimation of genomic breeding values;Bayesian methods;BLUP methods

期刊名称:SCIENCE BULLETIN ( 影响因子:11.78; 五年影响因子:7.658 )

ISSN: 2095-9273

年卷期: 2016 年 61 卷 5 期

页码:

收录情况: SCI

摘要: Estimation of genomic breeding values is important in genomic selection. Bayesian and BLUP methods are the main techniques employed. In this study, we conducted a comparative study of BayesA, BayesB, BayesC pi and GBLUP methods in simulated data and real data of Chinese Holstein cattle. Results showed that, in simulated data, the accuracies of all methods were all similarly elevated with the increase of reference population size, but they made different responses to the changes of marker number or QTL number. In real data of Chinese Holstein cattle, BayesA generated the highest accuracy almost for all six traits, and GBLUP performed as well as BayesA for the traits of milk yield, fat yield and protein yield, while for the trait of fat percentage, protein percentage and somatic cell score, three Bayesian methods showed superior to GBLUP. Comprehensively analyzing above results, it can be speculated that accuracies of the three Bayesian methods are not only influenced by the absolute value of QTL number or marker number, but may also be influenced by the ratio of QTL number to marker number. And there is at least one kind of Bayesian methods performing better than GBLUP, when the ratio of QTL number versus marker number is very small or involving large-effect QTL.

分类号:

  • 相关文献

[1]Bayesian methods for estimating GEBVs of threshold traits. Wang, C-L,Ding, X-D,Wang, J-Y,Liu, J-F,Fu, W-X,Zhang, Z.,Yin, Z-J,Zhang, Q.,Wang, C-L.

[2]Achievements and prospects of genomics-assisted breeding in three legume crops of the semi-arid tropics. Varshney, Rajeev K.,Mohan, S. Murali,Gaur, Pooran M.,Pandey, Manish K.,Sawargaonkar, Shrikant L.,Chitikineni, Annapurna,Janila, Pasupuleti,Saxena, K. B.,Sharma, Mamta,Rathore, Abhishek,Mallikarjuna, Nalini,Gowda, C. L. L.,Varshney, Rajeev K.,Varshney, Rajeev K.,Varshney, Rajeev K.,Liang, Xuanqiang,Gangarao, N. V. P. R.,Pandey, Manish K.,Bohra, Abhishek,Pratap, Aditya,Datta, Subhojit,Chaturvedi, S. K.,Nadarajan, N.,Kimurto, Paul K.,Fikre, Asnake,Tripathi, Shailesh,Bharadwaj, Ch.,Anuradha, G.,Babbar, Anita,Choudhary, Arbind K.,Mhase, M. B.,Mannur, D. M.. 2013

[3]Incorporating Gene Annotation into Genomic Prediction of Complex Phenotypes. Gao, Ning,Zhang, Zhe,Yuan, Xiaolong,Zhang, Hao,Li, Jiaqi,Gao, Ning,Martini, Johannes W. R.,Simianer, Henner. 2017

[4]Genome-Wide Association Study and QTL Mapping Reveal Genomic Loci Associated with Fusarium Ear Rot Resistance in Tropical Maize Germplasm. Chen, Jiafa,Ding, Junqiang,Wu, Jianyu,Chen, Jiafa,Ding, Junqiang,Wu, Jianyu,Wu, Jianyu,Chen, Jiafa,Shrestha, Rosemary,Zheng, Hongjian,Mu, Chunhua,Mahuku, George,Zheng, Hongjian,Mu, Chunhua,Mahuku, George. 2016

[5]Improving accuracy of genomic prediction by genetic architecture based priors in a Bayesian model. Gao, Ning,Li, Jiaqi,He, Jinlong,Xiao, Guang,Luo, Yuanyu,Zhang, Hao,Chen, Zanmou,Zhang, Zhe,Gao, Ning,Zhang, Zhe. 2015

[6]Accuracy of genomic prediction for milk production traits in the Chinese Holstein population using a reference population consisting of cows. Ding, X.,Zhang, Z.,Li, X.,Wang, S.,Wu, X.,Sun, D.,Yu, Y.,Liu, J.,Wang, Y.,Zhang, Y.,Zhang, S.,Zhang, Y.,Zhang, Q.,Zhang, Z.. 2013

[7]Genetic parameters and trends for production and reproduction traits of a Landrace herd in China. Zhang Zhe,Zhang Hao,Pan Rong-yang,Wu Long,Li Ya-lan,Chen Zan-mou,Cai Geng-yuan,Li Jia-qi,Wu Zhen-fang. 2016

[8]Potential of marker selection to increase prediction accuracy of genomic selection in soybean (Glycine max L.). Li, Wenbin,Ma, Yansong,Liu, Zhangxiong,Guo, Yong,Qiu, Lijuan,Ma, Yansong,Luan, Xiaoyan,Reif, Jochen C.,Jiang, Yong,Wen, Zixiang,Wang, Dechun,Han, Tianfu,Wu, Cunxiang,Sun, Shi,Wei, Shuhong,Wang, Shuming,Yang, Chunming,Wang, Huicai,Yang, Chunming,Zhang, Mengchen,Lu, Weiguo,Xu, Ran,Zhou, Rong,Zhou, Xinan,Wang, Ruizhen,Sun, Zudong,Chen, Huaizhu,Zhang, Wanhai,Sun, Bincheng,Wu, Jian,Han, Dezhi,Yan, Hongrui,Hu, Guohua,Liu, Chunyan,Fu, Yashu,Chen, Weiyuan,Guo, Tai,Zhang, Lei,Yuan, Baojun.

[9]The strategy and potential utilization of temperate germplasm for tropical germplasm improvement: a case study of maize (Zea mays L.). Wen, Weiwei,Tovar, Victor H. Chavez,Taba, Suketoshi,Wen, Weiwei,Yan, Jianbing,Guo, Tingting,Li, Huihui. 2012

[10]Transcriptome Analysis Suggests That Chromosome Introgression Fragments from Sea Island Cotton (Gossypium barbadense) Increase Fiber Strength in Upland Cotton (Gossypium hirsutum). Quanwei Lu,Yuzhen Shi,Huang, Jinling,Yuan, Youlu,Xianghui Xiao,Pengtao Li,Juwu Gong,Wankui Gong,Aiying Liu,Haihong Shang,Junwen Li,Qun Ge,Weiwu Song,Shaoqi Li,Zhen Zhang,Md Harun or Rashid,Renhai Peng,Youlu Yuan,Jinling Huang. 2017

[11]Effect of Trait Heritability, Training Population Size and Marker Density on Genomic Prediction Accuracy Estimation in 22 bi-parental Tropical Maize Populations. Zhang, Ao,Liu, Yubo,Cui, Zhenhai,Ruan, Yanye,Yu, Haiqiu,Zhang, Ao,Wang, Hongwu,Liu, Yubo,Burgueno, Juan,San Vicente, Felix,Crossa, Jose,Zhang, Xuecai,Wang, Hongwu,Beyene, Yoseph,Semagn, Kassa,Olsen, Michael,Prasanna, Boddupalli M.,Cao, Shiliang,Semagn, Kassa. 2017

[12]Comparison of single-trait and multiple-trait genomic prediction models. Guo, Gang,Zhao, Fuping,Du, Lixin,Guo, Gang,Guo, Gang,Wang, Yachun,Zhang, Yuan,Guo, Gang,Su, Guosheng. 2014

[13]Genome-Wide SNP Discovery and Analysis of Genetic Diversity in Farmed Sika Deer (Cervus nippon) in Northeast China Using Double-Digest Restriction Site-Associated DNA Sequencing. Ba, Hengxing,Jia, Boyin,Wang, Guiwu,Yang, Yifeng,Li, Chunyi,Kedem, Gilead. 2017

[14]Accuracy of genomic prediction using low-density marker panels. Zhang, Z.,Ding, X.,Liu, J.,Zhang, Q.,Zhang, Z.,de Koning, D. -J.,Zhang, Z.,de Koning, D. -J.,de Koning, D. -J..

[15]Whole-genome strategies for marker-assisted plant breeding. Xu, Yunbi,Lu, Yanli,Gao, Shibin,Prasanna, Boddupalli M.. 2012

[16]A novel genomic selection method combining GBLUP and LASSO. Li, Hengde,Wang, Jingwei,Li, Hengde,Bao, Zhenmin,Wang, Jingwei.

作者其他论文 更多>>
  • Melatonin treatment delayed fruit softening by regulating postharvest carbohydrate metabolism of hami melon

    作者:Wang, Yue;Zhang, Weida;Li, Lingling;Yang, Wanting;Liu, Yuxing;Guo, Minrui;Chen, Guogang;Wang, Yue;Zhang, Weida;Li, Lingling;Yang, Wanting;Liu, Yuxing;Guo, Minrui;Chen, Guogang;Liu, Guang;Jiang, Li

    关键词:Shelf life; Cell wall; Sugar metabolism; Sucrose metabolism; Melon

  • Impact of Lactobacillus plantarum fermentation on jujube juice: Insights from intelligent sensory evaluation, tolerance index, and acidogenic potential

    作者:Cai, Wenchao;Fei, Liyue;Zhang, Dongsheng;Mao, Yiwen;Lu, Ziyi;Li, Yu;Wei, Suyu;Zhao, Xinxin;Zhang, Qin;Shan, Chunhui;Cai, Wenchao;Fei, Liyue;Zhang, Dongsheng;Mao, Yiwen;Lu, Ziyi;Li, Yu;Wei, Suyu;Zhao, Xinxin;Zhang, Qin;Shan, Chunhui;Cai, Wenchao;Fei, Liyue;Mao, Yiwen;Lu, Ziyi;Li, Yu;Wei, Suyu;Zhao, Xinxin;Zhang, Qin;Shan, Chunhui;Zhang, Dongsheng;Zheng, Qiangqing

    关键词:Lactobacillus plantarum; Jujube juice; Electronic nose; Electronic tongue; Tolerance index

  • Integrating large-scale meta-GWAS and PigGTEx resources to decipher the genetic basis of 232 complex traits in pigs

    作者:Xu, Zhiting;Lin, Qing;Cai, Xiaodian;Zhong, Zhanming;Teng, Jinyan;Zeng, Haonan;Gao, Yahui;Wei, Chen;Zhou, Jun;Zhang, Wenjing;Zhang, Xiaoke;Shi, Shaolei;Wu, Jun;Diao, Shuqi;Liu, Yuqiang;Pan, Xiangchun;Feng, Xueyan;Liu, Ruiqi;Su, Zhanqin;Chang, Chengjie;Zhu, Qianghui;Wu, Yuwei;Zhang, Hao;Yuan, Xiaolong;Li, Jiaqi;Zhang, Zhe;Li, Bingjie;Gao, Yahui;Liu, George E.;Gao, Yahui;Ma, Li;Cai, Zexi;Bai, Zhonghao;Su, Guosheng;Sahana, Goutam;Lund, Mogens Sando;Fang, Lingzhao;Wang, Xiaoqing;Shi, Liangyu;Zhao, Fuping;Wang, Xue;Wang, Yi;Zhang, Zipeng;Ding, Xiangdong;Lin, Yu;Tang, Guoqing;Li, Mingzhou;Li, Xuewei;Liu, Shuli;Yin, Hongwei;Bai, Lijing;Li, Kui;Zhou, Zhongyin;Wang, Qishan;Pan, Yuchun;Xu, Zhong;Peng, Xianwen;Mei, Shuqi;Mo, Delin;Liu, Xiaohong;Chen, Yaosheng;Liu, Yang;Xiang, Ruidong;Xiang, Ruidong;Shen, Xia;Shen, Xia;Shen, Xia;Li, Pinghua;Huang, Ruihua;Li, Pinghua;Huang, Ruihua;Ballester, Maria;Crespo-Piazuelo, Daniel;Amills, Marcel;Clop, Alex;Amills, Marcel;Karlskov-Mortensen, Peter;Fredholm, Merete;Zhang, Qin;Zhao, Yunxiang

    关键词:pig; meta-GWAS; PigGTEx; molQTL; complex traits

  • GRAMMAR-Lambda Delivers Efficient Understanding of the Genetic Basis for Head Size in Catfish

    作者:Zhao, Yunfeng;Zhao, Yunfeng;Jiang, Li;Gao, Jin;Feng, Hong

    关键词:linear mixed model; EMMAX; Ictalurus punctatus; morphology; genome-wide association study

  • Underappreciated role of canopy nitrogen deposition for forest productivity

    作者:Li, Xiaowei;Zhang, Chenlu;Zhang, Beibei;Jiang, Li;Tang, Shengqi;Sun, Chenhui;Bai, Yulong;Wang, Yubang;Shi, Yifei;Ma, Lei;Ort, Donald;Li, Xiaowei;Zhang, Chenlu;Zhang, Beibei;Jiang, Li;Tang, Shengqi;Sun, Chenhui;Bai, Yulong;Wang, Yubang;Shi, Yifei;Ma, Lei;Ort, Donald;Li, Xiaowei;Zhang, Chenlu;Shi, Yifei;Ort, Donald;Li, Xiaowei;Zhang, Chenlu;Zhang, Wei;Ye, Qing;Yan, Junhua;Wang, Keya;Ort, Donald;Shi, Yifei;Yan, Junhua;Wang, Keya;Fu, Juemin;Du, Wenzhi;Wan, Shiqiang;Hong, Liang;Fang, Yunting;Siemann, Evan;Luo, Yiqi;Reich, Peter B.;Reich, Peter B.;Reich, Peter B.

    关键词:nitrogen deposition; forest canopy; carbon sequestration; 15 N recovery

  • Canopy and understory nitrogen addition differentially regulate fine root decomposition in a temperate forest

    作者:Li, Xiaowei;Zhang, Chenlu;Zhang, Beibei;Jiang, Li;Sun, Chenhui;Bai, Yulong;Shi, Yifei;Fu, Shenglei;Li, Xiaowei;Zhang, Chenlu;Zhang, Beibei;Jiang, Li;Sun, Chenhui;Bai, Yulong;Fu, Shenglei;Li, Xiaowei;Zhang, Chenlu;Fu, Shenglei;Li, Xiaowei;Zhang, Chenlu;Fu, Shenglei;Shi, Yifei;Zhang, Wei;Ye, Qing;Yan, Junhua;Fu, Juemin;Du, Wenzhi;Ha, Denglong

    关键词:Nitrogen deposition; Forest ecosystem; Litter decomposition; Canopy N addition; Belowground carbon cycling; Understory N input

  • Effect of Melatonin Treatment on Antioxidant Metabolism and Storage Quality of "Fengtang" Plum

    作者:Zhang, Yun;Luo, Dengcan;Zhang, Qin;Lin, Xin;Peng, Junseng;Wan, Xuan;Huang, Shian;Dong, Xiaoqing;Ma, Yuhua

    关键词:"Fengtang" plums; postharvest; melatonin; quality; antioxidant