Testing the RothC and DNDC models against long-term dynamics of soil organic carbon stock observed at cropping field soils in North China

文献类型： 外文期刊

第一作者： Li, Shumin

作者： Li, Shumin;Li, Jumei;Li, Xiuying;Ma, Yibing;Li, Changsheng;Huang, Shaomin;Li, Shengxiu;Ma, Yibing

作者机构：

关键词： Long-term change;Soil organic carbon;DNDC;RothC

期刊名称：SOIL & TILLAGE RESEARCH （ 影响因子：5.374； 五年影响因子：6.368 ）

ISSN：

年卷期：

页码：

收录情况： SCI

摘要： RothC and DNDC, two process-based agroecosystem models widely utilized for quantifying soil carbon (C) sequestration, were tested against datasets of soil organic carbon (SOC) measured in two long-term experiments with winter wheat-summer maize rotation at field soils in North China. In the study, the two models were utilized in conjunction in three modes, i.e., using DNDC alone, using RothC driven by soil C inputs of measured crop residue, and using RothC driven by soil C inputs derived from DNDC simulations. In general, results from the three ways of simulations were in agreement with the measured SOC dynamics for the two experimental sites with varied treatments. However, discrepancies in the results revealed the differences between the two models regarding their functionality. The simulations with RothC driven by the measured crop residue as C input produced the best results on SOC dynamics in comparison with observations. Results from the simulations with DNDC alone were less correlated to observations mainly due to the approximation of the modeled amount of crop residue. Due to the same reason, the simulations with RothC but driven by DNDC-modeled crop residue poorly fit to observations. The results conclude that given the similarity between RothC and DNDC regarding their routines modeling SOC transformations it is crucial for improving the models' performance to provide accurate C input data (mainly crop residue) to the SOC turnover modules in the models. (C) 2016 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

分类号： S1

  • 相关文献

[1]Modeling the effects of farming management practices on soil organic carbon stock at a county-regional scale. Deng, Nanrong,Wang, Qi,Wang, Jing,Lv, Changhe,Yu, Haibin,Li, Wangjun,Chen, Zhao. 2018

[2]Impact of agricultural ntensification on soil organic carbon: A study using DNDC in Huantai County, Shandong Province, China. Liao Yan,Wu Wen-liang,Meng Fan-qiao,Liao Yan,Li Hu. 2016

[3]The development of China-DNDC and review of its applications for sustaining Chinese agriculture. Li Hu,Wang Ligang,Li Jianzheng,Gao Maofang,Zhang Jing,Zhang Jianfeng,Qiu Jianjun,Deng Jia,Changsheng Li,Frolking, Steve,Li Hu,Wang Ligang,Li Jianzheng,Gao Maofang,Zhang Jing,Zhang Jianfeng,Qiu Jianjun,Deng Jia,Changsheng Li,Frolking, Steve.

[4]A long-term sensitivity analysis of the denitrification and decomposition model. Qin, Xiaobo,Li, Yu'e,Gao, Qingzhu,Wan, Yunfan,Liu, Shuo,Liu, Yuntong,Qin, Xiaobo,Wang, Hong,McConkey, Brian,Brandt, Kelsey,Li, Yong,Lemke, Reynald,Li, Changsheng,Xu, Chao. 2013

[5]An Agricultural Tri-dimensional Pollution Data Management Platform Based on DNDC Model. Jiang, Lihua,Wang, Wensheng,Yang, Xiaorong,Xie, Nengfu,Jiang, Lihua,Wang, Wensheng,Yang, Xiaorong,Xie, Nengfu,Cheng, Youping. 2011

[6]Estimates of N2O Emissions and Mitigation Potential from a Spring Maize Field Based on DNDC Model. Li Hu,Qiu Jian-Jun,Wang Li-gang,Xu Ming-yi,Liu Zhi-qiang,Wang Wei. 2012

[7]Simulation and Prediction of Soil Organic Carbon Spatial Change in Arable Lands Based on DNDC Model. Wang, Deying,Yao, Yanmin,Si, Haiqing,Zhang, Wenju,Tang, Huajun. 2014

[8]Identifying critical nitrogen application rate for maize yield and nitrate leaching in a Haplic Luvisol soil using the DNDC model. Zhang, Yitao,Wang, Hongyuan,Liu, Shen,Lei, Qiuliang,Zhai, Limei,Liu, Hongbin,Liu, Jian,He, Jianqiang,Ren, Tianzhi.

[9]Modeling impacts of film mulching on rainfed crop yield in Northern China with DNDC. Han, Juan,Jia, Zhikuan,Wu, Wei,Han, Qingfang,Han, Juan,Jia, Zhikuan,Wu, Wei,Han, Qingfang,Li, Changsheng,Zhang, Jie.

[10]Soil carbon sequestration under long-term rice-based cropping systems of purple soil in Southwest China. Chen Qing-rui,Qin Yu-sheng,Chen Kun,Tu Shi-hua,Xu Ming-gang,Zhang Wen-ju. 2015

[11]Crop yield and soil carbon responses to tillage method changes in North China. Tian, Shenzhong,Ning, Tangyuan,Liu, Zhen,Li, Geng,Li, Zengjia,Tian, Shenzhong,Ning, Tangyuan,Lal, Rattan,Wang, Yu.

[12]Occlusive effect of soil aggregates on increased soil DTPA-extractable zinc under low soil pH caused by long-term fertilization. Guo, Z.,Guo, X.,Wang, J.,Wang, D.,Guo, Z.,Guo, X.,Wang, J.,Wang, D.. 2013

[13]Traditional manual tillage significantly affects soil redistribution and CO2 emission in agricultural plots on the Loess Plateau. Geng, Yan,Yu, Hanqing,Tarafder, Mahbubul,Li, Yong,Tian, Guanglong,Tian, Guanglong,Chappell, Adrian. 2018

[14]Phytolith accumulation in broadleaf and conifer forests of northern China: Implications for phytolith carbon sequestration. Yang, Xiaomin,Song, Zhaoliang,Hao, Qian,Zhang, Xiaodong,Liu, Hongyan,Van Zwieten, Lukas,Song, Alin,Li, Zimin,Wang, Hailong,Wang, Hailong. 2018

[15]Water-Stable Aggregates and Associated Carbon in a Subtropical Rice Soil Under Variable Tillage. Liu, Xi-Hui,Chen, Qiu-Shi,Huang, Yan-Fei,He, Ming-Ju,Xu, Fang-Long,Li, Yang-Rui,Gu, Ming-Hua,Ou, Hui-Ping,Liu, Xi-Hui,Huang, Yan-Fei,Tan, Hong-Wei,Li, Yang-Rui. 2016

[16]Spatiotemporal variation of soil organic carbon in the cultivated soil layer of dry land in the South-Western Yunnan Plateau, China. Zhao, Ji-xia,Liu, Gang-cai,Zhao, Ji-xia,Dai, Fu-qiang,He, Shou-jia,Zhang, Qing. 2017

[17]Characteristics of differently stabilised soil organic carbon fractions in relation to long-term fertilisation in Brown Earth of Northeast China. Xu, Xiangru,An, Tingting,Pei, Jiubo,Wang, Jingkuan,Xu, Xiangru,Zhang, Wenju,Xu, Minggang,Xiao, Jing,Xie, Hongtu. 2016

[18]Effects of Long-Term Organic Amendments on Soil Organic Carbon in a Paddy Field: A Case Study on Red Soil. Huang Qing-hai,Li Da-ming,Liu Kai-lou,Yu Xi-chu,Ye Hui-cai,Hu Hui-wen,Xu Xiao-lin,Wang Sai-lian,Zhou Li-jun,Duan Ying-hua,Zhang Wen-ju. 2014

[19]Crop residue, manure and fertilizer in dryland maize under reduced tillage in northern China: II nutrient balances and soil fertility. Wang, Xiaobin,Hoogmoed, Willem B.,Cai, Dianxiong,Perdok, Udo D.,Oenema, Oene. 2007

[20]Chemical fertilizers could be completely replaced by manure to maintain high maize yield and soil organic carbon (SOC) when SOC reaches a threshold in the Northeast China Plain. Li Hui,Feng Wen-ting,Sun Nan,Xu Ming-gang,Li Hui,Feng Wen-ting,He Xin-hua,Zhu Ping,Gao Hong-jun. 2017

作者其他论文 更多>>

微信小程序