Comparative analysis of GF-1, HJ-1, and Landsat-8 data for estimating the leaf area index of winter wheat

文献类型： 外文期刊

第一作者： Li He

作者： Li He;Chen Zhong-xin;Jiang Zhi-wei;Wu Wen-bin;Ren Jian-qiang;Liu Bin;Hasi, Tuya;Jiang Zhi-wei;Hasi, Tuya

作者机构：

关键词： GF-1 WFV;HJ-1 CCD;Landsat-8 OLI;leaf area index;PROSAIL;vegetation indices

期刊名称：JOURNAL OF INTEGRATIVE AGRICULTURE （ 影响因子：2.848； 五年影响因子：2.979 ）

ISSN： 2095-3119

年卷期： 2017 年 16 卷 2 期

页码：

收录情况： SCI

摘要： Using simultaneously collected remote sensing data and field measurements, this study firstly assessed the 'consistency and applicability of China high-resolution earth observation system satellite 1 (GF-1) wide field of view (WFV) camera, ' environment and disaster monitoring and forecasting satellite (HJ-1.) charge coupled device (CCD), and Landsat-8 operational land imager (OLI) data for estimating the leaf area index (LAI) of winter wheat via reflectance and vegetation indices (Vls). The accuracies of these LAI estimates were then assessed through comparison with an empirical model and the PROSAIL radiative transfer model. The effects of radiation calibration, spectral response functions, and spatial resolution on discrepancies in the LAI estimates between the different sensors were also analyzed. The results yielded the following observations: (1) The correlation between reflectance from different sensors is relative good, with the adjusted coefficients of determination (R-2) between 0.375 to 0.818. The differences in reflectance are ranging from 0.002 to 0.054. The correlation between Vls from different sensors is high with the R-2 between 0.729 and 0.933. The differences in the Vls are ranging from 0.07 to 0.156. These results show the three sensors' images can all be used for cross calibration of the reflectance and Vls. (2) The four Vls from the three sensors are all demonstrated to be highly correlated with LAI (R2 between 0.703 and 0.849). The linear models associated with the 2-band enhanced vegetation index (EVI2), which feature the highest R2 (higher than 0.746) and the lowest root mean square errors (RMSE) (less than 0.21), were selected to estimate the winter wheat LAI. The accuracy of the estimated LAI from Landsat-8 was the highest, with the relative errors (RE) of 2.18% and an RMSE of 0.1.3, while the HJ-1 was the lowest, with the RE of 2.43% and the RMSE of 0.15. (3) The inversion errors in the different sensors' LAI estimates using the PROSAIL model are small. The accuracy of the GF-1 is the highest with the RE of 3.44%, and the RMSE of 0.22, whereas that of the HJ-1 is the lowest with the RE of 4.95%, and the RMSE of 0.26. (4) The effects of the spectral response function and radiation calibration for the different sensors are small and can be ignored, but the effects of spatial resolution are significant and must be taken into consideration in practical applications.

分类号：

  • 相关文献

[1]Comparison of fractional vegetation cover estimations using dimidiate pixel models and look- up table inversions of the PROSAIL model from Landsat 8 OLI data. Ding, Yanling,Zhang, Hongyan,Li, Zhenwang,Xin, Xiaoping,Zheng, Xingming,Zhao, Kai,Zheng, Xingming,Zhao, Kai. 2016

[2]Estimation of crop LAI using hyperspectral vegetation indices and a hybrid inversion method. Liang, Liang,Zhang, Lianpeng,Lin, Hui,Liang, Liang,Zhao, Shuhe,Liang, Liang,Di, Liping,Deng, Meixia,Qin, Zhihao.

[3]Estimating crop chlorophyll content with hyperspectral vegetation indices and the hybrid inversion method. Liang, Liang,Zhao, Shuhe,Liang, Liang,Lin, Hui,Zhang, Lianpeng,Wang, Lijuan,Liang, Liang,Di, Liping,Zhang, Chao,Deng, Meixia,Qin, Zhihao,Zhao, Shuhe,Zhang, Chao,Liu, Zhixiao.

[4]MONITORING WINTER WHEAT MATURITY BY HYPERSPECTRAL VEGETATION INDICES. Wang, Qian,Huang, Yuanfang,Wang, Qian,Li, Cunjun,Wang, Jihua,Song, Xiaoyu,Huang, Wenjiang. 2012

[5]Evaluating Multispectral and Hyperspectral Satellite Remote Sensing Data for Estimating Winter Wheat Growth Parameters at Regional Scale in the North China Plain. Koppe, Wolfgang,Gnyp, Martin L.,Bareth, Georg,Koppe, Wolfgang,Chen, Xinping,Zhang, Fusuo,Li, Fei,Miao, Yuxin,Miao, Yuxin. 2010

[6]Multi-Temporal Hyperspectral and Radar Remote Sensing for Estimating Winter Wheat Biomass in the North China Plain. Hennig, Simon D.,Koppe, Wolfgang,Gnyp, Martin L.,Bareth, Georg,Chen, Xinping,Li, Fei,Miao, Yuxin,Jia, Liangliang. 2012

[7]New Vegetation Index Fusing Visible-Infrared and Shortwave Infrared Spectral Feature for Winter Wheat LAI Retrieval. Li Xin-chuan,Xu Xin-gang,Jin Xiu-liang,Zhang Jing-cheng,Song Xiao-yu,Li Xin-chuan,Xu Xin-gang,Jin Xiu-liang,Zhang Jing-cheng,Song Xiao-yu,Li Xin-chuan,Bao Yan-song. 2013

[8]Mapping tropical forests and deciduous rubber plantations in Hainan Island, China by integrating PALSAR 25-m and multi-temporal Landsat images. Chen, Bangqian,Li, Xiangping,Xiao, Xiangming,Zhao, Bin,Chen, Bangqian,Yang, Chuan,Wu, Zhixiang,Sun, Rui,Lan, Guoyu,Xie, Guishui,Xiao, Xiangming,Dong, Jinwei,Qin, Yuanwei,Xiao, Xiangming,Dong, Jinwei,Qin, Yuanwei,Kou, Weili. 2016

[9]Examining view angle effects on leaf N estimation in wheat using field reflectance spectroscopy. Song, Xiao,Feng, Wei,He, Li,Zhang, Hai-Yan,Li, Xiao,Wang, Chen-Yang,Guo, Tian-Cai,Song, Xiao,Xu, Duanyang,Wang, Zhi-Jie,Coburn, Craig A..

[10]Estimation of nitrogen status in middle and bottom layers of winter wheat canopy by using ground-measured canopy reflectance. Wang, ZJ,Wang, JH,Liu, LY,Huang, WJ,Zhao, CJ,Lu, YL. 2005

[11]Estimating N status of winter wheat using a handheld spectrometer in the North China Plain. Li, Fei,Jia, Liangliang,Miao, Yuxin,Yu, Zihui,Chen, Xinping,Zhang, Fusuo,Li, Fei,Gnyp, Martin L.,Koppe, Wolfgang,Bareth, Georg,Jia, Liangliang. 2008

[12]Nitrogen Status Estimation of Winter Wheat by Using an IKONOS Satellite Image in the North China Plain. Yu, Zihui,Li, Fei,Miao, Yuxin,Chen, Xinping,Zhang, Fusuo,Jia, Liangliang,Gnyp, Martin,Koppe, Wolfgang,Bareth, Georg. 2012

[13]Variations in crop variables within wheat canopies and responses of canopy spectral characteristics and derived vegetation indices to different vertical leaf layers and spikes. Li, Hell,Zhao, Chunjiang,Yang, Guijun,Feng, Haikuan.

[14]Detection of powdery mildew in two winter wheat cultivars using canopy hyperspectral reflectance. Zhou, Yilin,Duan, Xiayu,Cheng, Dengfa,Cao, Xueren,Luo, Yong.

[15]The optimal leaf area index for cucumber photosynthesis and production in plastic greenhouse. Xiaolei, S,Zhifeng, W. 2004

[16]Identification of plant configurations maximizing radiation capture in relay strip cotton using a functional-structural plant model. Lili Mao,Lizhen Zhang,Jochem B. Evers,Michael Henke,Wopke van der Werf,Shaodong Liu,Siping Zhang,Xinhua Zhao,Baomin Wang,Zhaohu Li.

[17]A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF SPECTRAL VEGETATION INDICES TO ESTIMATE CROP LEAF AREA INDEX. Fu, Yuanyuan,Yang, Guijun,Wang, Jihua,Feng, Haikuan,Fu, Yuanyuan,Yang, Guijun,Wang, Jihua,Feng, Haikuan,Fu, Yuanyuan,Wang, Jihua. 2013

[18]Aboveground dry matter and grain yield of summer maize under different varieties and densities in North China Plain. Li, Zongxin,Liu, Kaichang,Liu, Chunxiao,Zhang, Xiuqing,Liu, Xia,Zhang, Hui,Liu, Shucong,Wang, Qingcheng,Li, Zongxin,Liu, Kaichang,Liu, Chunxiao,Zhang, Xiuqing,Liu, Xia,Zhang, Hui,Liu, Shucong,Wang, Qingcheng,Li, Quanqi. 2013

[19]Comparison of high-yield rice in tropical and subtropical environments - I. Determinants of grain and dry matter yields. Ying, JF,Peng, SB,He, QR,Yang, H,Yang, CD,Visperas, RM,Cassman, KG. 1998

[20]Comparative Study on Remote Sensing Invertion Methods for Estimating Winter Wheat Leaf Area Index. Xie Qiao-yun,Huang Wen-jiang,Peng Dai-liang,Zhang Qing,Xie Qiao-yun,Liang Dong,Huang Lin-sheng,Zhang Dong-yan,Cai Shu-hong,Yang Gui-jun. 2014

作者其他论文 更多>>

微信小程序