Effect of different data quality control on evapotranspiration of winter wheat with Bowen ratio method

文献类型： 外文期刊

第一作者： Wu, Yingnan

作者： Wu, Yingnan;Li, Qiaozhen;Zhong, Xiuli;Gong, Daozhi;Liu, Xiaoying

作者机构：

关键词： Crop evaporation; Energy balance; Diurnal effect; Stage and seasonal effect; Invalid rejection

期刊名称：AGRICULTURAL WATER MANAGEMENT （ 影响因子：6.5； 五年影响因子：6.9 ）

ISSN： 0378-3774

年卷期： 2025 年 311 卷

页码：

收录情况： SCI

摘要： The Bowen ratio energy balance (BREB) method is widely used to study surface evapotranspiration, but its major drawback is the uncertainty when Bowen ratio (beta)-> -1. Various approaches have been employed to address this issue, but their performances were less evaluated via long-term field observations. Using data from three growing cycles, this study investigated the effect of five screening methods (Mth1 to Mth5 for -1 - |epsilon(1)| < beta < -1 + |epsilon(1)|, -1.05 < beta < -0.95, beta < -0.75, -1.3 < beta < -0.75 and beta < -0.7 or beta > 10 or Delta e <= 0, Delta e denotes the measured vapor pressure gradient, and epsilon(1) is a coefficient depending on sensor resolution and Delta e) on winter wheat evapotranspiration in northern China. On diurnal, daily and seasonal basis, the effect was in the order of Mth5 > Mth3 > Mth1 > Mth2 > Mth4, and the seasonal mean daily value of the gap-filled was 0.38, 0.22, 0.11, 0.01, and 0.01 mm d(-1) higher than the unfilled ones, yielding a seasonal total of 96.0, 53.5, 26.0, -0.9, and 0.4 mm, or 18.9 %, 11.4 %, 6.5 %, -0.2 %, and 0.1 % higher than the unfilled ones, respectively. These values resulted from the large difference in data rejection ranking as Mth5 > Mth3 > Mth1 > Mth4 > Mth2, seasonal mean daily 10-min rejection rate ranging from 15.4-73.2 %, 10.3-48.9 %, 5.3-44.9 %, 1.6-10.4 %, and 0.5-7.3 %, respectively (averaging 42.4 %, 30.5 %, 23.2 %, 5.7 %, and 2.6 %, respectively). The corresponding daily rejected hours ranged from 6.83-8.88, 3.60-6.11, 1.85-3.49, 0.10-0.39, and 0.07-0.33 h/day, respectively (averaging 7.53, 4.77, 2.90, 0.28, and 0.24 h/day, respectively), resulting in large data gaps for Mth5 (58.8 %), Mth3 (38.2 %), and Mth1 (17.5 %). Nighttime deletion dominated for Mth2 to Mth4, accounting for 61.1 %, 64.4 %, 68.3 %, and 63.2 % of the total deletion, whereas daytime deletion dominated for Mth1, accounting for 58.1 %. A large portion of invalid rejections of Mth1 (40.4 %-77.6 %), Mth3 (54.3 %-90.9 %) and Mth5 (61.8 %-92.7 %) was observed at the selected period, which was probably a consequence of the sensor's error cancellation effect, questioning the traditional a priori assumption that small vapor gradients within instrumental error should be discarded. Overall, large differences were observed and the simple Mth4 performed better than the more restrictive ones. These findings are expected to guide the selection of post-data processing in the application of BREB method.

分类号：

  • 相关文献
作者其他论文 更多>>

微信小程序