Economic and environmental indicators of sustainable rice cultivation: A comparison across intensive irrigated rice cropping systems in six Asian countries
文献类型: 外文期刊
作者: Devkota, Krishna Prasad 1 ; Pasuquin, Estela 1 ; Elmido-Mabilangan, Abigail 1 ; Dikitanan, Rowell 1 ; Singleton, 1 ;
作者机构: 1.IRRI, Sustainable Impact Platform, DAPO Box 7777, Manila 1301, Philippines
2.Chainat Rice Res Ctr, 2 Muang Dist, Muang Dist 17000, Chainat Prov, Thailand
3.Rice Dept, Phahonyothin Rd Chatujak, Bangkok 10900, Thailand
4.Agr Technol AIAT, Stad Maguwoharjo 22, Yogyakarta, Indonesia
5.RRDI, Batalagoda, Ibbagamuwa, Sri Lanka
6.DARD, Can Tho City, Vietnam
7.Beijing Inst Technol, Sch Management & Econ, 5 South Zhongguancun St, Beijing 100081, Peoples R China
8.Guangdong Acad Agr Sci, Rice Res Inst, Guangzhou 510640, Guangdong, Peoples R China
9.Africa Rice Ctr AfricaRice, 01 BP 2551, Bouake 01, Cote Ivoire
关键词: Yield gap; Profit gap; Economic sustainability; Environmental sustainability; Greenhouse gas emission; Nitrogen use efficiency; Water productivity; Sustainable intensification
期刊名称:ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS ( 影响因子:4.958; 五年影响因子:5.846 )
ISSN: 1470-160X
年卷期: 2019 年 105 卷
页码:
收录情况: SCI
摘要: Quantifying and comparing sustainability indicators are essential to improve the sustainability of smallholder rice cropping systems. The sustainability of rice production systems can be measured based on economic, environmental, social, and institutional indicators. In this paper, we restrict our assessment to economic and environmental indicators. During 2012-2015, farmers were interviewed from 847 households from intensively irrigated rice production regions in Vietnam, Thailand, Indonesia, Myanmar, Sri Lanka, and China. We assessed the sustainability of their farming practices using economic and environmental indicators, i.e., eight of the 12 performance indicators (PIs), as defined by the Sustainable Rice Platform (SRP). Across the six sites, there was a yield gap of 24-42% and a profit gap of 36-82% between the 10% highest-performing farms (mean of top decile) and the mean-performing farms. In addition, there was a labor productivity gap of 12-32%, a nitrogen use efficiency (NUE) gap of 11-20%, a phosphorus use efficiency (PUE) gap of 1-29%, and a water productivity gap of 12-42%. Deliberate modification of conventional practices, including not flooding the field for > 30 days before rice planting, incorporating pre-rice crop residue > 30 days before planting, and adoption of mid-season drainage or alternate wetting and drying irrigation rather than continuous flood irrigation during the rice growing period, could substantially reduce the greenhouse gas (GHG) emission in irrigated rice fields without yield penalty. There is an urgent need to adopt improved management strategies for nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P), potassium (K) fertilizer, irrigation water-use efficiency, as well as for decreasing pesticide use frequency, without sacrificing profitability and yield. We identified the following priority interventions for each site: a) increasing fertilizer use and adopting higher-yielding varieties in Bago, Myanmar; b) reducing pesticide application rates in Can Tho, Vietnam; c) reducing fertilizer use in Guangdong, China; d) reducing nitrogen and labor use in Yogyakarta, Indonesia; e) reducing fertilizer and water use in Polonnaruwa, Sri Lanka and; f) reducing fertilizer use in Nakhon Sawan, Thailand. Additional uses of the PI analysis clearly demonstrated that rice yield and profit gaps can sustainably be closed by increasing efficiencies that will also lead to reduced environmental footprint.
- 相关文献
作者其他论文 更多>>
-
Optimized nitrogen management improves grain yield of rice by regulating panicle architecture in South China
作者:Hu, Xiangyu;Liu, Yanzhuo;Zhong, Xuhua;Hu, Rui;Li, Meijuan;Peng, Bilin;Pan, Junfeng;Liang, Kaiming;Fu, Youqiang;Huang, Nongrong
关键词:Optimized nitrogen management; Panicle architecture; Rachis branch and floret; Differentiation; Degeneration
-
Determining nitrogen topdressing rates in accordance with actual seedling density and crop nitrogen status in direct-seeded rice
作者:Peng, Bilin;Wang, Xinyu;Hu, Xiangyu;Liu, Yanzhuo;Liang, Kaiming;Fu, Youqiang;Hu, Rui;Li, Meijuan;Ye, Qunhuan;Yin, Yuanhong;Pan, Junfeng;Zhong, Xuhua;Peng, Bilin;Wang, Xinyu;Hu, Xiangyu;Liu, Yanzhuo;Liang, Kaiming;Fu, Youqiang;Hu, Rui;Li, Meijuan;Ye, Qunhuan;Yin, Yuanhong;Pan, Junfeng;Zhong, Xuhua
关键词:direct-seeded rice; maximum tiller number; nitrogen management; plant nitrogen status; actual seedling density
-
Evaluating Rice Varieties for Suitability in a Rice-Fish Co-Culture System Based on Lodging Resistance and Grain Yield
作者:Li, Meijuan;Hu, Xiangyu;Hu, Rui;Liang, Kaiming;Zhong, Xuhua;Pan, Junfeng;Fu, Youqiang;Liu, Yanzhuo;Wang, Xinyu;Ye, Qunhuan;Yin, Yuanhong
关键词:rice-fish co-culture system; rice varieties; lodging resistance; grain yield; paddy field screening
-
Mitigation of environmental N pollution and greenhouse gas emission from double rice cropping system with a new alternate wetting and drying irrigation regime coupled with optimized N fertilization in South China
作者:Liang, Kaiming;Zhong, Xuhua;Fu, Youqiang;Hu, Xiangyu;Li, Meijuan;Pan, Junfeng;Liu, Yanzhuo;Hu, Rui;Ye, Qunhuan
关键词:Nitrogen loss; Greenhouse gas emissions; Water saving irrigation; Water productivity; South China
-
Improving grain yield and nitrogen use efficiency of direct-seeded rice with simplified and nitrogen-reduced practices under a double-cropping system in South China
作者:Fu, Youqiang;Huang, Nongrong;Zhong, Xuhua;Liu, Yanzhuo;Liang, Kaiming;Pan, Junfeng;Hu, Xiangyu;Hu, Rui;Li, Meijuan;Ye, Qunhuan;Zhong, Xuhua;Liang, Kaiming;Mai, Guoxun;Pan, Huarong;Xu, Haoqi;Xiao, Jie
关键词:grain yield; nitrogen use efficiency; simplified and nitrogen-reduced practice; direct-seeded rice
-
Growth, nutrient uptake and transcriptome profiling of rice seedlings in response to mixed provision of ammonium- and nitrate-nitrogen
作者:Fu, Youqiang;Zhong, Xuhua;Lu, Chusheng;Liang, Kaiming;Pan, Junfeng;Hu, Xiangyu;Hu, Rui;Li, Meijuan;Ye, Qunhuan;Liu, Yanzhuo
关键词:Ammonium; and nitrate -nitrogen; Roots and shoots; Plant growth; Nutrient uptake and translocation; Differentially expressed genes (DEGs); Rice
-
Phloem Unloading in Developing Rice Caryopses and its Contribution to Non-Structural Carbohydrate Translocation from Stems and Grain Yield Formation
作者:Li, Guohui;Cui, Kehui;Hu, Qiuqian;Wang, Wencheng;Pan, Junfeng;Zhang, Guo;Shi, Yange;Nie, Lixiao;Huang, Jianliang;Peng, Shaobing;Li, Guohui;Pan, Junfeng;Nie, Lixiao
关键词:Cell wall invertase; Non-structural carbohydrates; Plasmodesma; Rice (Oryza sativa L; ); Sucrose transporter; Symplasmic and apoplasmic unloading