A Comparison of Moment-Independent and Variance-Based Global Sensitivity Analysis Approaches for Wheat Yield Estimation with the Aquacrop-OS Model
文献类型: 外文期刊
作者: Upreti, Deepak 1 ; Pignatti, Stefano 2 ; Pascucci, Simone 2 ; Tolomio, Massimo 1 ; Li, Zhenhai 3 ; Huang, Wenjiang; 1 ;
作者机构: 1.Univ Tuscia, Dipartimento Sci Agr & Forestali DAFNE, Via San Camillo de Lellis, I-01100 Viterbo, Italy
2.CNR, Ist Metodol Anal Ambientale CNR, IMAA, Via Fosso del Cavaliere 100, I-00133 Rome, Italy
3.Beijing Res Ctr Informat Technol Agr, China Natl Engn Res Ctr Informat Technol Agr NERC, Beijing 100097, Peoples R China
4.Chinese Acad Sci, Aerosp Informat Res Inst, Beijing 100094, Peoples R China
关键词: AOS; Morris; EFAST; PAWN; parameters; density-based
期刊名称:AGRONOMY-BASEL ( 影响因子:3.417; 五年影响因子:3.64 )
ISSN:
年卷期: 2020 年 10 卷 4 期
页码:
收录情况: SCI
摘要: The present work reports the global sensitivity analysis of the Aquacrop Open Source (AOS) model, which is the open-source version of the original Aquacrop model developed by the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO). Analysis for identifying the most influential parameters was based on different strategies of global SA, density-based and variance-based, for the wheat crop in two different geographical locations and climates. The main objectives were to distinguish the model's influential and non-influential parameters and to examine the yield output sensitivity. We compared two different methods of global sensitivity analysis: the most commonly used variance-based method, EFAST, and the moment independent density-based PAWN method developed in recent years. We have also identified non-influential parameters using Morris screening method, so to provide an idea of the use of non-influential parameters with a dummy parameter approach. For both the study areas (located in Italy and in China) and climates, a similar set of influential parameters was found, although with varying sensitivity. When compared with different probability distribution functions, the probability distribution function of yield was found to be best approximated by a Generalized Extreme Values distribution with Kolmogorov-Smirnov statistic of 0.030 and lowest Anderson-Darling statistic of 0.164, as compared to normal distribution function with Kolmogorov-Smirnov statistic of 0.122 and Anderson-Darling statistic of 4.099. This indicates that yield output is not normally distributed but has a rather skewed distribution function. In this case, a variance-based approach was not the best choice, and the density-based method performed better. The dummy parameter approach avoids to use a threshold as it is a subjective question; it advances the approach to setting up a threshold and gives an optimal way to set up a threshold and use it to distinguish between influential and non-influential parameters. The highly sensitive parameters to crop yield were specifically canopy and phenological development parameters, parameters that govern biomass/yield production and temperature stress parameters rather than root development and water stress parameters.
- 相关文献
作者其他论文 更多>>
-
Comparison of three models for winter wheat yield prediction based on UAV hyperspectral images
作者:Xu, Xiaobin;Teng, Cong;Zhu, Hongchun;Li, Zhenhai;Teng, Cong;Feng, Haikuan;Zhao, Yu
关键词:hyperspectral imagery; unmanned aerial vehicle; winter wheat; yield prediction model; remote sensing
-
Remote sensing of quality traits in cereal and arable production systems: A review
作者:Li, Zhenhai;Fan, Chengzhi;Li, Zhenhai;Zhao, Yu;Song, Xiaoyu;Yang, Guijun;Jin, Xiuliang;Casa, Raffaele;Huang, Wenjiang;Blasch, Gerald;Taylor, James;Li, Zhenhong
关键词:Remote sensing; Quality traits; Grain protein; Cereal
-
Estimation of grain filling rate of winter wheat using leaf chlorophyll and LAI extracted from UAV images
作者:Zhang, Baoyuan;Gu, Limin;Dai, Menglei;Bao, Xiaoyuan;Zhen, Wenchao;Zhang, Baoyuan;Dai, Menglei;Bao, Xiaoyuan;Sun, Qian;Zhang, Mingzheng;Qu, Xuzhou;Gu, Xiaohe;Zhen, Wenchao;Zhen, Wenchao;Li, Zhenhai;Zhen, Wenchao
关键词:Grain filling rate; UAV; Winter wheat; Vegetation index
-
Coupled maize model: A 4D maize growth model based on growing degree days
作者:Qian, Binxiang;Huang, Wenjiang;Ye, Huichun;Guo, Anting;Pan, Yuhao;Jin, Yin;Jiao, Quanjun;Zhang, Biyao;Qian, Binxiang;Huang, Wenjiang;Ye, Huichun;Guo, Anting;Pan, Yuhao;Jin, Yin;Jiao, Quanjun;Qian, Binxiang;Huang, Wenjiang;Ye, Huichun;Guo, Anting;Pan, Yuhao;Jin, Yin;Jiao, Quanjun;Huang, Wenjiang;Ye, Huichun;Guo, Anting;Xie, Donghui;Xie, Qiaoyun;Ruan, Chao;Xu, Tianjun;Zhang, Yong;Nie, Tiange
关键词:Remote sensing; Maize growth model; 4D maize growth model; Maize canopy parameters; Growing degree days (GDDs); Coupled maize model
-
ChinaWheatYield30m: a 30 m annual winter wheat yield dataset from 2016 to2021 in China
作者:Zhao, Yu;Han, Shaoyu;Zheng, Jie;Xue, Hanyu;Li, Zhenhai;Meng, Yang;Yang, Xiaodong;Yang, Guijun;Zhao, Yu;Meng, Yang;Han, Shaoyu;Li, Zhenhai;Li, Xuguang;Cai, Shuhong;Li, Zhenhong;Yang, Guijun
关键词:
-
A comparison of methods to estimate leaf area index using either crop-specific or generic proximal hyperspectral datasets
作者:Nie, Chenwei;Shi, Lei;Xu, Xiaobin;Yin, Dameng;Li, Shaokun;Jin, Xiuliang;Li, Zhenhai;Xu, Xiaobin
关键词:Leaf area index; Hyperspectral remote sensing; PROSAIL-D; Vegetation indices; Crop
-
Comparison and transferability of thermal, temporal and phenological-based in-season predictions of above-ground biomass in wheat crops from proximal crop reflectance data
作者:Li, Zhenhai;Zhao, Yu;Song, Xiaoyu;Meng, Yang;Feng, Haikuan;Xu, Xingang;Chen, Liping;Yang, Guijun;Li, Zhenhai;Taylor, James;Gaulton, Rachel;Jin, Xiuliang;Li, Zhenhong;Li, Zhenhong;Chen, Pengfei;Wang, Chao;Guo, Wei
关键词:Crop biomass algorithm; Phenological scale; Proximal reflectance; UAV hyperspectral; Winter wheat