Genomic selection for hard-to-measure traits in aquaculture: Challenges in balancing genetic gain and diversity
文献类型: 外文期刊
作者: Kang, Ziyi 1 ; Kong, Jie 1 ; Li, Qi 3 ; Sui, Juan 1 ; Dai, Ping 1 ; Luo, Kun 1 ; Meng, Xianhong 1 ; Chen, Baolong 1 ; Cao, Jiawang 1 ; Tan, Jian 1 ; Fu, Qiang 1 ; Wang, Zhaoxin 4 ; Luan, Sheng 1 ;
作者机构: 1.Chinese Acad Fishery Sci, Yellow Sea Fisheries Res Inst, State Key Lab Mariculture Biobreeding & Sustainabl, Qingdao 266071, Shandong, Peoples R China
2.Qingdao Marine Sci & Technol Ctr, Lab Marine Fisheries Sci & Food Prod Proc, Qingdao 266237, Shandong, Peoples R China
3.Ocean Univ China, Fisheries Coll, Qingdao 266003, Peoples R China
4.BLUP Aquabreed Co Ltd, Weifang 261312, Peoples R China
关键词: The family-based selective breeding program; Genomic selection; Long-term selection; Genetic diversity; Conversion efficiency
期刊名称:AQUACULTURE ( 影响因子:3.9; 五年影响因子:4.4 )
ISSN: 0044-8486
年卷期: 2025 年 606 卷
页码:
收录情况: SCI
摘要: Genomic selection (GS) is being actively evaluated in aquaculture for its enhanced prediction accuracy over traditional pedigree-based selection (PS). However, the long-term efficiency of GS for the hard-to-measure trait in family-based aquaculture breeding programs remains unclear. This study simulated a typical family-based breeding program for Pacific white shrimp, focusing on a hard-to-measure trait with low heritability (0.10), to investigate genetic gain, genetic diversity, and conversion efficiency (CE) at the genome level. The impacts of panel density, reference group size, and genotype imputation on these metrics were assessed. GS increased genetic gain by 15.57 % to 113.29 % compared to PS when using panel densities of 12 to 1250 SNPs per chromosome. However, GS reduced genetic diversity by 6.36 % to 41.23 %, and decreased CE by 16.54 % to 57.60 % relative to PS, primarily due to poor within-family prediction accuracy, which biased the selection of candidates and the optimization of mating plans. When the within-family prediction accuracy reached 0.7, the CE of GS became comparable to that of PS. Genotype imputation improved CE in GS, particularly at panel densities of 3 to 23 SNPs per chromosome. Genotype imputation increased CE by 23.04 % to 158.72 % compared to non-imputed GS and by 9.70 % relative to PS. The reference group size and panel density exhibited inflection points in their impacts on the genetic gain and CE of GS. Beyond thresholds (panel density: 114 SNPs per chromosome; reference group size: 70 individuals per family), additional resource allocations resulted in significantly diminishing returns. Moreover, the inflection point for panel density was more pronounced than that for reference group size, as evidenced by the lack of significant CE improvements in GS when reference group sizes expanded from 30 to 200 individuals per family. Our findings highlight that managing within-family diversity in GS poses significant challenges, which negatively affect CE and the sustainability of breeding schemes. Nevertheless, low-density SNP panels combined with genotype imputation offer a cost-effective and practical strategy for achieving superior genetic gains while maintaining sustainability. Breeders should prioritize optimizing panel density when implementing GS under resource-limited conditions.
- 相关文献
作者其他论文 更多>>
-
Copy Number Variations in Short Tandem Repeats Modulate Growth Traits in Penaeid Shrimp Through Neighboring Gene Regulation
作者:Zhou, Hao;Qiang, Guangfeng;Xia, Yan;Tan, Jian;Fu, Qiang;Luo, Kun;Meng, Xianhong;Chen, Baolong;Chen, Meijia;Sui, Juan;Dai, Ping;Li, Xupeng;Liu, Mianyu;Kong, Jie;Luan, Sheng;Zhou, Hao;Qiang, Guangfeng;Xia, Yan;Tan, Jian;Fu, Qiang;Luo, Kun;Meng, Xianhong;Chen, Baolong;Chen, Meijia;Sui, Juan;Dai, Ping;Li, Xupeng;Liu, Mianyu;Kong, Jie;Luan, Sheng;Xing, Qun
关键词:short tandem repeats; STR; growth trait; penaeid shrimp; molecular breeding
-
Genomic selection of resistance to acute hepatopancreatic necrosis disease in Litopenaeus vannamei
作者:Liu, Mianyu;Li, Xupeng;Kong, Jie;Meng, Xianhong;Luo, Kun;Sui, Juan;Dai, Ping;Tan, Jian;Cao, Jiawang;Chen, Baolong;Luan, Sheng;Liu, Mianyu;Li, Xupeng;Kong, Jie;Meng, Xianhong;Luo, Kun;Sui, Juan;Dai, Ping;Tan, Jian;Cao, Jiawang;Chen, Baolong;Luan, Sheng;Wang, Hongjie
关键词:Genomic selection; Single-step genomic evaluation; Progeny testing; AHPND resistance; Litopenaeus vannamei
-
Study on deep learning-based detection method of key points of unconstrained Pacific white shrimp in water
作者:Zhang, Xiujun;Fang, Su;Jin, Zechao;Luan, Sheng
关键词:phenotypic data; deep learning; Pacific white shrimp; key point detection; unconstrained measurement
-
Genomic Evaluation of Harvest Weight Uniformity in Penaeus vannamei Under a 3FAM Design Incorporating Indirect Genetic Effect
作者:Gao, Siqi;Tian, Yi;Gao, Siqi;Xia, Yan;Kong, Jie;Meng, Xianhong;Luo, Kun;Sui, Juan;Dai, Ping;Tan, Jian;Li, Xupeng;Cao, Jiawang;Chen, Baolong;Fu, Qiang;Liu, Junyu;Luan, Sheng;Gao, Siqi;Xia, Yan;Kong, Jie;Meng, Xianhong;Luo, Kun;Sui, Juan;Dai, Ping;Tan, Jian;Li, Xupeng;Cao, Jiawang;Chen, Baolong;Fu, Qiang;Liu, Junyu;Luan, Sheng;Xing, Qun
关键词:
Penaeus vannamei ; harvest weight uniformity; indirect genetic effects; H matrix; genetic parameters -
Genomic selection strategies to overcome genotype by environment interactions in biosecurity-based aquaculture breeding programs
作者:Kang, Ziyi;Kong, Jie;Sui, Juan;Dai, Ping;Luo, Kun;Meng, Xianhong;Chen, Baolong;Cao, Jiawang;Tan, Jian;Fu, Qiang;Luan, Sheng;Kang, Ziyi;Kong, Jie;Sui, Juan;Dai, Ping;Luo, Kun;Meng, Xianhong;Chen, Baolong;Cao, Jiawang;Tan, Jian;Fu, Qiang;Luan, Sheng;Kang, Ziyi;Li, Qi;Xing, Qun
关键词:
-
Genetic parameter estimation of tolerance traits for ammonia-nitrogen and nitrite-nitrogen in Urechis unicinctus
作者:Zhang, Wei;Wang, Kai;Ma, Yanqing;Lai, Wenyuan;Shao, Mingyu;Zhao, Yongzheng;Wang, Hongtao;Zhang, Zhifeng;Ma, Yubin;Zhang, Zhifeng;Sui, Juan;Chen, Zongtao
关键词:Ammonia-nitrogen; Nitrite-nitrogen; Genetic parameters; Selective breeding; Urechis unicinctus
-
Plankton community diversity-driven mutualism in medium-salinity ponds enhances growth of pacific white shrimp Penaeus vannamei
作者:Li, Ying;Wang, Yunfei;Zhang, Jihong;Sun, Yiru;Kong, Jie;Li, Ying;Zhang, Jihong;Wang, Yunfei
关键词:Salinity; Pacific white shrimp Penaeus vannamei; Plankton community; Aquaculture ponds; Environmental factors



